Unlocking Customer Growth by Targeting Competitor Weaknesses

April 23, 2024

Understanding and leveraging your competitors’ weaknesses through competitor analysis, particularly in terms of their advertising and marketing strategies, is an extremely powerful tool for ecommerce brands. More than just keeping an eye on the competition, competitor analysis empowers brands to identify and exploit gaps and opportunities that they may have otherwise overlooked.

With the rise of digital marketing, mountains of competitor data can easily be mined for deeper insights into their tactics, from keyword usage in SEO and paid search campaigns to the content and offers they present across online platforms like social media, YouTube, and more.

For example, a detailed keyword analysis can reveal which terms your competitors target in their paid search efforts, allowing you to identify and capture underserved audiences. Understanding which platforms your competitors dominate—and those they neglect—can help you invest more wisely by focusing on less saturated platforms to avoid high costs. 

By examining competitors’ unique selling propositions, such as free shipping or discounts for new customers, you can craft marketing messages that highlight your distinct offerings, attracting their customers to your brand.

While targeting competitor weaknesses is a potent tool, it is critical to use it wisely, as there can also be downsides to these techniques. This article discusses specific tools and strategies for conducting competitor analysis and leveraging the data you gather to gain an edge in the market.

Identifying Weaknesses: How to Spot Opportunities in Competitor Strategies

Critical analysis provides a foundation for enhancing your marketing efforts and steering your business toward growth. Here, we discuss the most effective methods for uncovering competitor vulnerabilities, which can significantly influence both your paid and organic marketing tactics.

Here’s are some key methods to identify competitor weaknesses:

  • Customer Feedback Analysis: Review customer feedback to uncover real-world problems with competitor products, such as poor quality or inadequate service, and adjust your marketing to address these pain points.
  • Comprehensive Keyword Analysis: Identify keywords competitors target and those they overlook to find opportunities for your brand to attract underserved audiences.
  • Ad Copy and Creative Examination: Evaluate competitors’ ad copy, CTAs, imagery, and videos to find gaps like outdated content or ineffective messaging, and craft more engaging content to stand out.
  • Seasonality and Market Timing: Analyze competitors’ campaign timing to launch your promotions during underutilized periods, like certain holidays or seasonal peaks, to capture more market share.
  • Technological and Process Gaps: Assess the technology and processes your competitors use, identifying areas for improvement where you can implement superior technology or more innovative content strategies to gain an edge.

Essential Competitor Analysis Tools

For direct-to-consumer brands, understanding the competitive landscape is crucial for strategic decision-making and achieving growth. A variety of tools are available to help uncover valuable insights about competitors’ strategies, ranging from their keyword usage and ad spend to the effectiveness of their advertising creatives. 

  • SEMrush: Provides detailed insights on competitors’ keyword targeting in both paid and organic search, types of ads they run, traffic volumes, and the landing pages they use, helping understand their conversion strategies and audience engagement.
  • SpyFu: Offers extensive historical data, showing every keyword competitors have bid on in Google Ads, their organic rankings, and ad variations for the past 17 years, helping identify long-term trends and shifts in competitors’ strategies.
  • Google Ads’ Keyword Planner: Assists in discovering new keyword opportunities by showing likely competitor bids and the potential cost of these keywords, aiding in effective budgeting and ROI optimization.
  • Google’s Auction Insights: Provides data on ad overlap with competitors, ad position relative to competitors, and impression share, essential for adjusting bids and strategies to enhance search ad visibility and effectiveness.
  • Ad Transparency Center: Allows visibility into the ads competitors are running across Google’s search network, YouTube, and the Display Network, offering insights into their messaging and creative strategies, useful for developing more engaging and distinctive ads.

Custom Intent Audiences: Targeting Competitor Customers Effectively

Targeting competitor customers can be a strategic move to capture market share and drive growth, but traditional search campaigns targeting competitor keywords often lead to high costs per click (CPC) and low Quality Scores due to restrictions on using competitor names in ad copy or landing pages. 

A more cost-effective and efficient method to target these customers is through custom intent audiences on platforms like YouTube and the Google Display Network.

Custom intent audiences are designed for advertisers who want to go beyond basic demographic and location targeting to engage with users based on the specific actions they take online. This includes the keywords they search for or the content of the websites they visit.

Creating custom intent audiences allows brands to target users who have shown interest in your competitors without directly bidding on competitor names or trademarks, which can be legally sensitive and expensive. 

Utilizing custom intent audiences typically results in much lower CPC rates compared to search campaigns that target competitor keywords, which can become prohibitively expensive. Additionally, platforms like YouTube and the Google Display Network allow for broader reach, displaying ads across a wide array of sites and videos and catching users at various stages of their online activities, thereby increasing the chances of engagement.

To effectively utilize custom intent audiences, follow these steps:

  1. Identify Competitor Keywords and URLs: Start by compiling a list of keywords and URLs associated with competitors. These should be terms and sites that potential customers of your competitors are likely to visit.
  2. Create Audience Lists: Use platforms like Google Ads to create custom intent audiences based on the identified keywords and URLs. This list will target users who have shown interest in related topics or competitor products.
  3. Develop Tailored Ad Content: Craft your ad content to directly address the needs and interests of this audience. Highlight what sets your brand apart from competitors, focusing on unique selling points or advantages over the competition.
  4. Choose Appropriate Landing Pages: Ensure that the landing pages linked to from your ads are highly relevant and offer a compelling reason for users to switch from the competitor to your brand. It can be beneficial to create specific landing pages that directly compare your product’s features against those of your main competitors.
  5. Monitor and Optimize: Continuously track the performance of your campaigns and make adjustments based on what resonates with the audience. Optimization might involve tweaking the ad copy, adjusting bids, or refining the targeting criteria based on audience response and conversion rates.

Risk Management: Balancing Aggressive Growth with a Smart Strategy

While the use of competitor analysis can be a useful tool for driving growth and capturing market share, it comes with risks that must be managed to ensure long-term sustainability and effectiveness. By understanding these risks and adopting strategies to mitigate them, brands can maintain a balanced approach to competitor analysis, ensuring it complements other marketing efforts without overwhelming them. Potential risks of targeting competitor weaknesses in your marketing strategy include:

  • Increased Costs: One of the most immediate risks of targeting competitors directly, especially through search campaigns, is the potential for significantly higher CPC. As brands bid on competitive keywords, the auction environment can become increasingly expensive, diminishing the return on investment (ROI).
  • Bid Wars: When brands aggressively target competitor keywords, there is a risk of instigating bidding wars. Competitors may respond by bidding on your branded terms, driving up your marketing costs and potentially reducing the effectiveness of your typically lower-cost branded campaigns.
  • Overemphasis on Competitors: Focusing too heavily on competitor actions can divert attention from understanding and responding to customer needs and market trends. This overemphasis can lead to a reactive rather than proactive strategy, where decisions are made in response to competitors’ actions rather than based on what is best for the brand and its customers.

It is crucial to continuously review the impact of competitor-focused strategies on your overall marketing goals. Regularly assessing these campaigns’ effectiveness in terms of customer acquisition costs, impact on brand perception, and contribution to overall sales enables informed adjustments. 

Adaptation and Evolution: Staying Ahead in a Dynamic Market

Staying ahead of competitors is not just about identifying their current weaknesses—it’s about being adaptive and responsive when they evolve. For DTC brands, the ability to quickly adapt and evolve marketing strategies in response to competitors’ changes is crucial. This section discusses strategies for maintaining a competitive edge by continually updating and refining marketing approaches as competitors improve or change their offerings.

  • Continuous Competitor Analysis: Conduct regular (monthly) reviews to stay informed about competitors’ new ads, product launches, or strategy changes.
  • Leveraging Customer Loyalty and Unique Selling Propositions: Continuously emphasize the strengths that make loyal customers prefer your brand.
  • Innovative Product Development: Proactively enhance product quality and user experience and introduce new features to stay ahead of the competition and maintain industry leadership.
  • Rapid Response Marketing: Maintain a flexible marketing strategy that can quickly adapt to include new messaging and tactics in response to competitor changes.
  • Educational and Engagement-Driven Content: Focus on creating content that educates and engages your audience, deepening customer relationships and distinguishing your offerings from competitors.
  • Technology and Tools: Keep up with the latest digital marketing trends and tools, from new Google Ads campaign types to advancements in SEO and content marketing, to efficiently capture new customer segments.
  • Risk Management in Adaptation: Avoid overreacting to competitors’ changes; maintain a balanced approach that focuses on long-term strategy and sustainable spending.

By embracing a proactive and strategic approach to competitor analysis and adaptation, DTC brands can continually capture and retain customers by staying relevant and responsive.

Measuring Success: Key Metrics for Assessing Competitor-Focused Strategies

When implementing strategies focused on exploiting competitor weaknesses, measuring success goes beyond looking at conversions and revenue. It’s crucial to employ a variety of metrics to get a comprehensive view of how effectively the strategy is influencing potential customers at different stages of their journey. 

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

  • Conversions: A conversion can be a sale, a sign-up, or another action that is valuable to your business. Monitoring the conversion rate helps gauge the effectiveness of your competitor-focused strategies at turning prospects into customers.
  • Upper Funnel Metrics: These include indicators such as:
    • Email List Sign-Ups: Capturing email addresses from visitors who may not be ready to purchase but are interested enough to engage further.
    • Time on Site and Page Views: Measures engagement and interest; more time or more pages viewed suggests deeper interest in your offerings.
    • Number of Sessions per User: Indicates the frequency of interaction with your site, which can signal rising interest or consideration.
  • Impression Share: This metric is particularly useful in paid search campaigns. It shows the percentage of impressions your ads receive compared to the total number of impressions your ads could get. A high impression share in campaigns targeting competitor keywords might indicate strong visibility against competitors.
  • Cost Per Click (CPC): While traditionally a metric to monitor for cost management, in the context of targeting competitors, a change in CPC can indicate increased competition for keywords or greater efficacy in your ad placements.

Using Metrics to Adapt and Optimize

Measuring these KPIs allows brands to not only see what is working but also identify what aspects of their competitor-focused strategies might need adjustment. For example:

  • High Engagement but Low Conversion Rates: This might suggest that while the initial ad or content is effective at drawing in users, there may be issues with the landing pages or the checkout process that need optimization.
  • Low Impression Share: Indicates that your ads are not being shown as often as they could be, possibly due to budget constraints or high competition for keywords. Adjusting bids or exploring less competitive keywords could be beneficial.
  • High CAC: If the cost of acquiring customers is unsustainable, consider refining target audiences, improving conversion rates through A/B testing, or enhancing customer retention strategies to increase LTV.

By continuously monitoring these metrics, brands can ensure their strategies to exploit competitor weaknesses remain effective and adjust as necessary when market conditions or competitor behaviors change. This approach not only helps in achieving short-term goals but also supports sustainable growth and market positioning in the long term.

In conclusion, effectively targeting competitor weaknesses through thorough competitor analysis not only differentiates your brand but strategically positions it to capture market share, driving growth and enhancing customer acquisition.

About the Author: Laura Benoit is a Senior Media Analyst at adQuadrant. Originally from Boston, MA, Laura moved to San Diego in 2021 and enjoys exploring California via beaches, hikes, and burrito shops. A graduate of Emmanuel College, she began her marketing career in higher education before transitioning to digital marketing agencies where she’s been for the past 5 years.

More Articles